23 May 2007
In the first week of May, 200-odd Van Gujjar families started moving towards their summer homes in Uttarkashi district, Uttarakhand. They had been stranded around Vikasnagar near Dehradun before a response to a right to information application revealed that Uttaranchal’s forest department had rescinded an earlier decision to bar Van Gujjars from entering their summer homes in the state. It’s a temporary respite though. Uttaranchal’s forest department has made it clear that it will not allow Van Gujjars to enter the state’s forest next year.
Van Gujjars are traditional migrants, practising transhumance—moving up with their livestock herds into the higher reaches of the Himalaya during summers and coming down to the Shivalik in Uttar Pradesh in winters.
Their summer home falls in the Govind National Park (gnp) in Uttarkashi district—the temporary permission allows them to enter the adjacent Govind Wildlife Sanctuary (gws). G S Pandey, director of Rajaji National Park, who also has charge of gnp, says: “This year we are giving permission to these families who come from Uttar Pradesh to go to gws. This will not be so next year.”
Praveen Kaushal ‘Manto’, director of the Society for Promotion of Himalayan Indigenous Activities, a Dehradun-based ngo working for the Van Gujjars, which filed the right to information application, says that the permission letter is dated April 25, 2007. But the Van Gujjars knew nothing of this until April 30, when Kaushal received a response to his application.
Conflict this year
“In the Shivalik, the Van Gujjars pay a ‘lopping tax’ and they pay a ‘grazing tax’ in gws. After paying these taxes they are given permits—a legally admissible document. This is a record of rights—since 1937 at least,” says Kaushal. The 12 Van Gujjar families which were allocated permits in 1937 have multiplied to about 100 nuclear units. The number of permits remains 12 though.
This year in April, when the 12 permit holders (100-odd nuclear families) went to the park authorities for permission (as they do every year), they were denied. “When we were leaving for the Shivaliks this year, the forest officers made us give it to them in writing that we won’t come back. But where do we go, unless alternative arrangements are made,” asks Ulfa, a Van Gujjar.
As a result of a rumour, about 100 other families who go to gws also stopped dead in their tracks. “Being stranded with livestock in the mountains is not a very pleasant proposition for us since we move with all our belongings in tow,” says Roshan, another Van Gujjar.
As a result of the delay in getting permission, the Van Gujjars ran out of fodder that they move with. “I had to buy fodder from a village here. As our fodder demands went up, so did the prices. I just paid Rs 1,000 for four sacks of fodder, which will last for two feedings for the cattle,” says Ulfa. “The buffaloes suffered miscarriages and the calves—and our kids—fell sick. We are not used to the heat and cannot survive in it,” the Gujjars say collectively.
Fight for survival
A June 2003 permanent order of the principal chief conservator of forests, Uttaranchal (now Uttarakhand), said that Van Gujjars go through a lot of trouble arranging for permission, but the process should be made easy for them.
But in September 2006, came a superseding order, which made the Van Gujjars sign documents saying they would not come back to gnp. Park officials say that the pressure on forest has increased with the original 12 permit holding families multiplying into 100-odd nuclear units.
At present the state has no plans to resettle Van Gujjars, says Pandey. “One has to settle them slowly, they have no skills or specialisations—not even as labourers,” says Kaushal. He contends that no law bans rights just because the dependents also go to another state. But the order of the chief wildlife warden clearly states that the Van Gujjars will be made to give it in writing that they will not return next year. The chief wildlife warden of the state was not available for comment.
Nikka Kasana, a young Van Gujjar put the state of affairs in perspective: “Confrontation has been deferred, but only till we have to move up again.”
News Source: http://www.downtoearth.org.in